How to Sell Old Coins in South Africa (2024)

Last updated on December 11th, 2023 at 03:31 pm

Are you intrigued by the glint of history nestled within your old South African coins? Well, you’re not alone!

Old coins can be more than just currency – they can be valuable treasures that hold historical significance and collector’s appeal.

Whether you’re a seasoned numismatist or just stumbled upon a stash of old coins in your attic, the idea of selling these relics might have crossed your mind.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through the process of selling old coins in South Africa, from determining their value to finding reputable buyers. So, dust off those coins and let’s dive into the world of numismatic treasure hunting!

Do Old South African Coins Have Value?

Yes, indeed! Old South African coins can hold substantial value, depending on factors such as rarity, condition, and historical significance. Here are some remarkable old South African coins that have garnered substantial worth:

The 1898 Single 9 Pond coin, a true crown jewel, commands an estimated value of over a whopping R23 million!
The Kruger Double Nine Ponds coin, another gem, boasts a worth of around R1 million.
The Burgers Pond Coarse Beard coin, with its unique appeal, carries a value of approximately R100,000.
The Sammy Marks Tickey coin, a delightful find, dances around a worth of about R50,000.
The Mandela 90th Birthday coin, a tribute to an icon, stands at an impressive value of around R150,000.

Even common old South African coins can fetch a few cents or even a few dollars, depending on their condition.

It’s like having a time machine in your pocket! To unveil the worth of your coins, consider seeking an appraisal from a seasoned coin dealer or auction house.

You might just be sitting on a goldmine, quite literally!

Factors That Influence Coin Value

Remember, it’s not just about the age – several factors play into the value of old South African coins:

Rarity: The scarcer the coin, the more desirable it becomes. Rarity creates demand, and demand drives up the value.
Condition: A well-preserved coin is a sought-after coin. The better the condition, the higher the value. Think of it as giving your coins a little spa day!
Historical Significance: Coins that have a story to tell carry extra weight (pun intended) in the value game. They might commemorate significant events or personalities.

Where Can You Sell Old Coins in South Africa?

Now that you’ve uncovered the potential treasures within your old coins, where can you transform these historical gems into cold, hard cash? Fear not, for South Africa offers various avenues for your numismatic endeavors:

1. City Coins

City Coins, a trusted guide in the world of numismatics, provides opinions and advice rooted in over four and a half decades of industry experience. With a broad spectrum of knowledge, they can assess the worth of your old South African coins, including banknotes from across the globe.

2. Facebook Groups

In the age of social media, Facebook groups dedicated to buying and selling old South African coins and banknotes have flourished.

Groups like “Buy and Sell Old South African Antique Coins” and “We Buy and Sell Coins and Other Things in South Africa” create a virtual marketplace for numismatic enthusiasts.

3. Online Marketplaces: The Digital Bazaar

E-commerce platforms like eBay, OLX, Quikr, IndiaMart, and Coinbazaar offer a digital marketplace to showcase your coins and banknotes to a global audience. It’s like having a virtual storefront for your numismatic treasures.

4. Coin Dealers: Your Trusted Advisors

Professional coin dealers possess the expertise to guide you through the selling process. They can provide insights into the value of your old South African banknotes and ensure a smooth transaction.

5. Auction Houses: The Grand Stage

Auction houses offer a stage where your coins can shine under the spotlight. Selling your old South African banknotes through auctions can attract serious collectors and enthusiasts alike.

Remember, the value of old South African banknotes can fluctuate based on market conditions and demand. So, take your time, do your research, and explore the avenues that best suit your numismatic journey.

How to Authenticate Old South African Money

As you embark on your numismatic quest, ensuring the authenticity of your old South African banknotes becomes paramount. Here’s how you can confidently identify genuine treasures:

1. Check the Security Features

Old South African banknotes boast security features that safeguard against counterfeiting. Look for watermarks, security threads, and microprinting. The South African Reserve Bank’s website is a treasure trove of information on these features.

2. Look for Signs of Wear and Tear

While a bit of history’s patina adds character, excessive wear and tear might raise authenticity concerns. Examine for creases, tears, and stains. A well-preserved banknote not only assures authenticity but also holds higher value.

3. Consult a Professional

When in doubt, seek wisdom from the masters. Professional coin dealers and numismatists possess the trained eye to validate the authenticity of old South African banknotes.

4. Leverage Online Resources

The digital age offers a plethora of resources at your fingertips. The South African Reserve Bank’s website and online forums dedicated to numismatics can provide valuable insights into authentication techniques.

Remember, the value of old South African banknotes can sway with the tides of time, so authenticating them ensures you’re not merely holding history, but a piece of genuine treasure.

Safeguarding Value Through Proper Storage

Preservation is the key to safeguarding the value of your old South African money. Proper storage ensures your numismatic treasures continue to shine through the ages:

1. Protective Sleeves or Holders

Envelop your banknotes in protective sleeves or holders designed for currency storage. These shields guard against dust, moisture, and physical damage, preserving the allure of history.

2. Keep Away from Sunlight

Just like vampires, old banknotes shy away from direct sunlight. Shield them from UV rays to prevent colors from fading, ensuring your treasures remain vibrant.

3. Handle with Care

Before caressing your coins, ensure your hands are clean and free from oils and dirt. Minimize the risk of transferring unwanted marks onto your banknotes.

4. Limit Excessive Handling

Overzealous handling can usher in wear and tear. Handle your banknotes with a light touch to maintain their pristine condition.

5. Acid-Free Envelopes or Albums

For those with a penchant for collections, acid-free envelopes or albums provide a safe haven. Shield your banknotes from harmful substances that accelerate deterioration.

6. Maintain Ideal Humidity and Temperature

Banknotes, much like fine wine, thrive in stable environments. Shield them from humidity and temperature fluctuations to ensure they age gracefully.

7. Beware of Chemicals

Banknotes don’t appreciate chemical company. Keep them far from substances that emit corrosive fumes, shielding them from potential harm.

Your preservation efforts become the bridge between generations, ensuring the value of your old South African money remains undiminished.

Selling Old Coins Through Banks in South Africa

While most banks in South Africa offer exchanges for old coins, it’s important to note that the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) doesn’t buy back circulation coins. Gold coins like Krugerrands, Protea, or Natura series gold coins, however, may find a home in the SARB’s embrace. And, if you’re seeking a trustworthy avenue, the South African Gold Coin Exchange (SAGCE) awaits your old coins.

Selling to the South African Reserve Bank

When it comes to old coins, the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) doesn’t engage in buying back circulation coins. But fear not, for if you possess gold coins like Krugerrands, Protea, or Natura series gold coins, the SARB may offer you a warm reception. Present your treasures to the gold coin teller at the SARB Head Office in Pretoria, armed with proof of residence, ID, and a bank statement. It’s your golden ticket to potential treasure!

The Most Coveted Old South African Coins for Cash

Ah, the moment of truth – which old South African coins are the most coveted by collectors and enthusiasts alike? Here’s a glimpse into the allure of numismatic treasures:

Single 9 Pond (1898): This rare marvel claims the title of South Africa’s most valuable coin, boasting an astounding R15 million in value!
Kruger Double Nine Ponds (1899): With only 130 minted, this rarity stands tall at a worth of around R1.5 million each.
Burgers Pond Coarse Beard (1874): With a scarcity of 142, this beauty holds a value of about R1 million.
Sammy Marks Tickey (1898): A mere 215 in existence, this coin dances to a value of around R50,000.
1892 Zuid Afrikansche Republiek 5 Shillings: This silver delight translates to a value of $350-$400 USD, embracing history in its gleam.
1947 Suid-Afrika Georgivs VI Rex Imperator 5 Shillings: Commemorating history, this coin finds itself valued at $70-$80 USD.
1952 South Africa Georgivs Sextvs Rex 5 Shillings: A testament to times gone by, this coin treasures a value of $20-$25 USD.
1940 South Africa Suid-Afrika 2 1/2 Shillings: In its silver sheen, this coin fetches a value of $20-$30 USD.

Certainly! Here’s a comparison table showcasing the most coveted old South African coins along with their estimated values:

Coin Name	Year	Rarity	Estimated Value (in Rands)	Estimated Value (in USD)
Single 9 Pond	1898	Extremely Rare	Over R15 million	–
Kruger Double Nine Ponds	1899	Very Rare	Around R1.5 million each	–
Burgers Pond Coarse Beard	1874	Rare	Around R1 million	–
Sammy Marks Tickey	1898	Rare	Around R50,000	–
1892 Zuid Afrikansche Republiek 5 Shillings	1892	–	–	$350 – $400 USD
1947 Suid-Afrika Georgivs VI Rex Imperator 5 Shillings	1947	–	–	$70 – $80 USD
1952 South Africa Georgivs Sextvs Rex 5 Shillings	1952	–	–	$20 – $25 USD
1940 South Africa Suid-Afrika 2 1/2 Shillings	1940	–	–	$20 – $30 USD

Remember, the value journey for old coins is an intriguing one, woven with history, rarity, and collector’s fervor.

Final Thoughts

The world of selling old coins in South Africa holds a blend of excitement and potential. Your coins, each a piece of history, can find new life in the hands of collectors and enthusiasts.

From authentication to storage, from trusted dealers to sought-after coins, your numismatic journey is a thrilling one.

So, dust off those coins, embrace the history they carry, and embark on a path of discovery – one coin at a time!